Tools for Promoting Literacy
Ronald W. Kirk
January 2003
Once, men looked up to Christians because they wielded wisdom,
understanding, and accomplishment. With their Christ-centered
foundation, they spoke with meaning and relevance to a dying world.
Christians were often the most accomplished musicians, scientists,
statesmen, and writers of their day, many leaving a distinguished
mark on history. Christians were the head and not the tail. Sound
intellectual development rose in part from rigorous literary
training. For many, the Bible was life's textbook, and this
accounted for much success. Today these things are not commonly so.
Recovering the basic tools of literacy will help reverse that damage
and lead to a new frontier of Christian achievement.
I find it somewhat ironic that I am writing this article. I grew
up in a home with little literary inclination, though with a
powerful work ethic. While always a voracious learner, I have also
struggled with verbal expression. I acquired the ability to read in
spite of "Dick and Jane." Although supposedly well
educated with a degree from the University of California at Berkeley
in a professional discipline, from my early moments as an aspiring
Christian educator, I had to strive to re-build my own elementary
education. I believe that God appointed me to this work as an
encouragement to others who also struggle to learn or to teach.
Modern education often discourages the desire for personal
accomplishment. We come to believe we cannot learn. Bad psychology
and poor methods permanently arrest our faculties. These things
ought not to be. A remedy is at hand. The best encouragement I can
offer is that if I can learn and attain modest ability,
anyone can. I can also share the grounds of my success in teaching
and learning.
The Rudiments of Literacy
All sound learning builds upon the Biblical tripod of education: example,
content, and discipline. These three elements clearly
appear in the way Christ taught His disciples. Most contemporary
teaching methods emphasize either content (the cognitive
view) or example (the environmental view), although the affective
view (how one feels) has also gained prominence. In recent decades,
discipline — practice under an appropriate level of government —
has largely fallen into disrepute. Nonetheless, the three elements
together comprise a rightly balanced approach to learning.
As to example, the ordinary use of elevated language in
the home or school greatly serves the cause of literacy. Children
will acquire their basic vocabulary, the needed foundation of
literacy, from the use of language in the home. I have found that
the home that loves literature and learning, in practice and
together as a family, produces the greatest inclination to learning
in the children. Regular family reading aloud makes a significant
impact on the heart and mind of the child. Because of his natural
commanding influence, the father's shared literary interest is
particularly important.
As to content, we recognize that language is first oral;
the root of language means tongue. Based on agreement
over the meaning of articulate sounds, we communicate thought, mind
to mind. Written language substitutes characters for the sounds of
speech. Clearly, then, the sounds of speech and their representative
letters comprise the most fundamental elements of literacy. Seventy
or so basic phonograms (letters or combinations of letters) and
about forty phonemes (basic phonic sounds) comprise the building
blocks for the whole of the English language. A system that
concentrates on these basic sounds and their letter representations
is more efficient than one that exercises with a multiplicity of
possible consonant and vowel combinations, as in the common early
phonetic systems.1 Certain essential rules uniformly
govern the assembly of the individual phonograms into words. These
few rules guide the writing and reading of most English words. Such
rules as guide syllabication and adding suffixes simplify learning a
complex language like ours. Moreover, systematic learning ordinarily
and very quickly helps build a sense of spelling for those
patterns too numerous to learn under formal rules. The basic
phonetic elements, a concise set of governing rules, and specific
practice in spelling words provide an efficient and portable method
adaptable to individual needs. The content of literature used to
teach reading ought to correspond to the high standard of content
appropriate to all Christian consumption. I have long used and
recommend the original McGuffey's Readers.2
As to discipline, directed practice carves ability into
the native faculties. We apply ourselves to both the principle and
the particular. We know that sin confounds the faculties so that
only consistent correct practice may unscramble them. The
command, "Do this and live!" guides our faith. Few are
good at any endeavor at first. Specific and precise exercise
establishes the various neural pathways we recognize as development
in knowledge, skills, and character. To learn, the student must
overcome the natural reticence to undertake anything difficult.
Difficulty yields to accomplishment in due season. We must believe
that God Himself enables our ability. We practice the subject by
faith in proper sequence, from the rudiments to the more demanding
and advanced. Learning is not linear, and demanding accomplishment
from one not ready is cruel. However, anyone can try. Anyone
can improve. Accepting a period of investment without immediate
fruit produces faith, patience, and the character for overcoming
difficulty. Within weeks, upon an intensive investment in the
mastery of the phonograms, almost any child can learn to read. No
one I have taught has failed to read, including children and adults
labeled dyslexic. Teachers of those who are physically or mentally
handicapped can often find alternative means or use conventional
means at a slower pace. Being a slower learner should not exclude a
willing student from opportunity. A monolithic classroom pace
necessarily restrains the more able and overwhelms the slower
learner. In all cases, overcoming difficulty by faith remains the
essential principle of learning. Dyslexic children recover. Children
with speech impediments improve. Bright children soar, commonly
spelling and reading at the fourth through seventh grade level by
the end of their primary years (the time when the early literacy
skills are begun, usually kindergarten and first grade).
In teaching literacy, I recommend balancing the student's various
communication faculties — seeing, listening, speaking, and writing
in every combination. While many children favor visual or auditory
learning, they should exercise the weaker faculty as well as the
stronger one. Learning to write on notebook paper from a blackboard
exercises the eye in distance and near reading. This practice also
trains a necessary spatial skill. Discerning top, bottom, left side,
right side, and middle may be new to the young learner. Good posture
serves to support the scholarly and most intellectual pursuits of
modern man, as well as health. Good ergonomics help keep adults from
injury. Forming the habit of good posture will similarly serve the
child into old age. The teacher should self-consciously and
particularly instruct, exemplify, and guide the practice of every
skill needed for learning.
The Essential Learning Principle
God's truth finds expression in the simplest and most elegant forms,
though ultimate expression is ever so complex and demanding. The
simple statement "Love God and love your neighbor"
supports the whole of the law and prophets and finds its full
expression only in the seemingly infinite details of life's living.
Although the actual constituents of physical motion are very
complex, Isaac Newton's idealized formula regarding force and
movement —F=MA — provides a very useful instrument for
predicting motion. Every individual is composed of parts, themselves
discrete wholes of some kind, such as the organs and cells of a
body. In turn, every whole forms a part of some greater whole. The
inherent relationship of the whole to its constituting parts
provides the philosophical ground for forming summarizing, abstract
concepts of all kinds. For convenience and utility, most knowledge
can thus be reduced abstractly to simple, general statements
collected from the complex parts that comprise the whole. For
example, a school classroom is made of individual students. A
fraction of the classroom may be taken without damaging the students
(students love this graphic illustration). God's gift of abstraction
provides the faculty needed to subdue and organize the individual
topics of every complex subject for Christian dominion. This
essential organizational principle is the essential learning
principle.
The principle of related wholes and parts thus anchors the
literacy paradigm. Rote learning of the basic phonograms and their
sounds first establishes the basis for forming words, and then
sentences, paragraphs and larger units of human thought. The student
quickly applies the phonograms to the spelling and reading of words.
These are sequenced, in the beginning, from easy to more difficult.
Students should, at first, learn and practice words on a phonetic
basis. Later, the phonetically composed words appear as readable
wholes. Still later, the student should read larger phrases and even
sentences as discrete wholes. Such a skill comprises the basis for
faster reading comprehension.
First attempts to separate a word into its recognizable
phonograms present a formidable obstacle to discerning the word.
Learning basic individual words in spelling lists assists the new
learner in this endeavor. However, the young reading student will
nonetheless often encounter words within his spoken vocabulary that
are not yet readable by him. The student then seeks to discern
phonograms that produce a recognizable word. Since a given letter
combination can form different phonograms in different words, the
reader must be a word detective. For example, er may often
form a single basic phoneme (phonetic sound) as in other, or
may sound separately as in era or error. Once the
student has recognized his troublesome word, he ought to practice
reading it phonetically several times, so that he may recognize it
next time as a whole word. Because reading for whole thoughts is his
goal, after decoding a difficult word, the student should re-read
his sentence from the beginning. For a new reader, this can be a
very tedious process. However, the procedure is necessary both for
the particular reading skill and for the capacity for faith in any
given effort. The teacher ought not to short-circuit the process,
prematurely supplying a sought phonogram or word. The teacher better
serves the student by guiding his search as needed, whenever
possible.
The student may encounter a word beyond his vocabulary. At first,
the young student may require his teacher to supply a definition.
Later the student should learn to use the dictionary to discern a
word's contextual meaning. Rigorous teaching of the English roots,
suffixes, and prefixes greatly aids mastery of the language. These
are skills learned from assiduous application and are usually
acquired over an extended period.
The sentence is the first whole unit of human thought. Unless one
can read and understand the sentence as a whole, communication of
the intended thought remains incomplete. Again, a student may have
to read and re-read a sentence many times to master it. However, as
important as the sentence is, it is only the beginning of
understanding. The paragraph represents the extended treatment of a
single idea. In order to read a paragraph, as with sentence and word
decoding, the student must understand its parts. More advanced
elementary students determine a paragraph's essential idea from the
discernment of an overall single subject and predicate. We ask: What
is the paragraph about? What does the paragraph essentially say
about the subject?
If a student cannot understand a paragraph, he must parse or
dissect the sentences. If he cannot understand a sentence, he must
discern the words' meanings in context. If he cannot identify or
does not know the meaning of a word, he must discover it. He then
works to build understanding of the greater whole. If an element of
reading is more difficult to understand, it is likely to be more important.
Out of innate laziness — an aspect of the sin nature — many
students tend to skip over difficult things. For true learning, the
opposite should be true. Due to the vagaries of thought and
language, the most important ideas are often expressed only with
difficulty. Understanding is an economic principle, a matter of
investment. Here too, students must learn to walk by faith and
patience.
The whole and parts principle applies to extended expressions of
a whole, single idea, such as chapters, books, and systems. Alas,
"Of the writing (and reading) of books, there is no end, and it
is wearying to the soul." Nonetheless, this system is
accessible. A home school mom once told me that she gained more
understanding from this simple paradigm than she learned in two
years of graduate study as a reading major.
With application to the minute details of learning, with the
establishment of humble faith and character in the pursuit of
learning, and with the regular application of the principle of the
whole and parts, while incorporating the best content, sound
literacy should result. Such a general accomplishment in the young
and old and among those of greater and lesser native ability will go
far toward restoring the ability of Christians to acquire Biblical
wisdom, and once more to be the head and not the tail, to the glory
of God.
Notes
1. See Romalda Spalding, Writing Road to Reading (New
York: Morrow, 1990). However, the consonant-vowel approach, such as
Noah Webster's or Alexander McGuffey's spelling systems, or Samuel
Blumenfeld's Alpha-Phonics (Boise: The Paradigm Company,
1991), may offer an easier means to combine the phonetic
sounds. Including exercises with consonant and vowel combinations
may be helpful for students who experience difficulty learning this
skill.
2. The Original McGuffey's Eclectic Series, by
William H. McGuffey, is published by Mott Media.
Ronald Kirk is engaged in research and development promoting
Chalcedon's work to the Christian education market. Please write!
Ron would enjoy receiving your feedback, with any questions, dialog
or request for educational topics, at ronaldwkirk@goldrush.com.
|